How we pick
The process behind every recommendation here, including the parts most gear sites leave out.
Last updated
The short version
We research products from manufacturer specifications, current retail listings and buyer feedback read in full. We rank them on fit for a specific job. We publish the reasoning and link the sources, and where a figure is not published anywhere, we say so instead of estimating it.
The result is a page you can act on: a clear top pick for each job, the specification that decided it, and a link to the source of every number.
1. Finding candidates
For each category we build a candidate list from:
- Current retail listings in the category — what is actually sold right now
- The product lines professional installers buy, where those are available to retail
- Buyer feedback, read in volume, looking for repeated failure patterns rather than star counts
- Manufacturer documentation, where it exists and states something checkable
A product that is discontinued, out of stock everywhere, or exists only as a listing with no identifiable manufacturer does not make the list.
2. What decides a pick, by category
The criteria differ per category because the failure modes differ. These are the ones that actually drive our rankings:
- Light sets — whether bulbs are individually replaceable, wire gauge, lens material, published rated life, connectability and the end-to-end chain limit.
- Clips — which mounting surfaces the shape genuinely grips, which bulb formats the gripper holds, body weight (which decides whether it survives a cold takedown), and pack sizes against a real roofline.
- Timers and smart plugs — amp rating against a 15-amp circuit, outlet count, weather housing, safety certification, and whether the control type actually tracks sunset.
- Cords — jacket rating (SJTW), conductor gauge, amp rating and plug construction.
- Inflatables — what ships in the box, internal lighting evenness, fabric and seam construction as described, and whether replacement blowers are obtainable.
- Anchors — length, material, shape and whether tethers are included, because a stake with nothing to tie to it anchors nothing.
- Storage — reel material, bag fabric and coating, handle construction and stated capacity against a real display.
3. Where the figures come from
Every number on this site can be traced to a source you can open yourself. That is what makes a comparison worth reading, and it is how each of these pages is built:
- Quote the manufacturer, and attribute it. When this site says a bulb is rated at 60,000 hours, that is the manufacturer’s published figure and it is linked on the page.
- Reason from design. A polycarbonate lens survives a fall that would shatter glass; a socketed set is repairable and a molded one is not; a 12-inch steel anchor resists pull-out better than a 6-inch plastic one. Those are properties of the design, not test results, and we present them as such.
- Point you to the published number. Where a maker publishes a wind rating, a fabric denier, a load figure or a rated life, it is quoted and linked on the page, so the comparison is between figures you can check for yourself.
4. What the scores mean
Every ranked product carries a score out of 10. It is editorial judgment against the criteria above for that category — how well the product suits the job, what it gives up, and how it compares with the alternatives on the same page.
A score is a compressed version of the reasoning on the page. Read the reasoning and you can see exactly what earned it, which is what makes two scores in the same category worth comparing.
What each band means. The criteria and their weights are the ones listed above; the bands below are the published scale those criteria are read against:
- 9.5 – 9.8 — category-defining. The product the rest of the category is measured against. Buy it and the decision is closed.
- 9.0 – 9.4 — outstanding. Does the job as well as anything sold, and wins outright for the specific case it is listed under.
- 8.4 – 8.9 — excellent, and strongly recommended. A genuinely good buy with one trade-off worth knowing about before you order — usually size, fit or price.
There is no fourth band. A product that would score below 8.4 against these criteria is not recommended here at all: it is left off the page rather than listed with a low number. That is why every score on this site sits between 8.4 and 9.8 — the scale describes the products that survived the selection above, not every product on the market.
5. What disqualifies a product
- No identifiable manufacturer or product line
- Specifications that cannot be verified anywhere
- Discontinued, or no current listing
- A repeated, documented failure pattern in buyer feedback
- Marketing claims that contradict the physical design
- Safety certification absent in a category where it matters, such as outdoor timers
6. Prices
Prices come from live retailer data, shown with the date they were captured and refreshed daily, so the figure you act on is the current one. A figure older than 48 hours is replaced automatically.
When that happens the buy button reads “Check price on Amazon” and takes you straight to the live listing, which is why you will find prices on the buy controls rather than typed into the body text of a page.
7. How often pages are re-checked
- Roundups and comparisons — reviewed ahead of each season, and whenever a product in them is discontinued or substantially changed.
- Guides — reviewed when the underlying facts change, which for electrical conventions and mounting practice is rarely.
- Corrections — made as soon as we know, with the updated date changed so the change is visible.
8. Independence
No placement on this site is paid for, no manufacturer has any say in what appears here, and commission rates are not an input to any ranking. Several pages recommend the cheaper option, and a few recommend buying nothing at all.
The full independence rules are in the editorial policy, and how the site makes money is on the affiliate disclosure page.